Pelorus

ESG

ESG due diligence: what funds actually ask SMEs for (and what stalls deals)

ESG questionnaires in due diligence are not scoring your virtue. They are looking for traceable data, over three years. What makes the exercise fail, and how to prepare.

By Matteo Icart 9 min read

The scenario repeats itself. The valuation is traced, the business plan holds up, the acquirer is serious. Then an eighty-line file lands, titled ESG questionnaire, with a ten-day deadline. And the founder discovers they cannot answer questions about their own company.

It is almost never a performance problem. It is a data problem.

Why funds ask these questions

An investment fund is not questioning you out of conviction. It is questioned itself. Its own subscribers — insurers, pension funds, family offices — require consolidated indicators across its entire portfolio, and it can only produce them by collecting from each holding.

The consequence is concrete: the request is recurring, not one-off. Answering once under pressure settles nothing, since the same collection returns every year.

What a questionnaire actually contains

Three blocks, always the same ones, with varying depth depending on who is asking.

BlockWhat is requestedWhere the data sits
EnvironmentEnergy consumption, scope 1 and 2 emissions, accessible scope 3 categories, waste, water where relevantEnergy and fuel invoices, accounts payable, fleet records
SocialHeadcount, gender split, turnover, absenteeism, workplace accidents, training hoursPayroll software, personnel register, training plan
GovernanceBoard composition, formalised policies, conflict-of-interest handling, supply-chain exposureArticles, minutes, framework contracts

None of this data is exotic. Nearly all of it already exists somewhere in the company. The problem lies elsewhere.

What makes the exercise fail

The obstacle is not the level of performance. A fund knows perfectly well that an industrial SME emits more than a software publisher, and does not expect otherwise.

What stalls things is the inability to produce the data in time and explain where it came from. Three symptoms recur:

  • The data exists but nobody knows where. Energy consumption sits in PDF invoices spread across three mailboxes. Rebuilding three years takes two unplanned weeks.
  • Two departments give two different figures. Year-end headcount differs depending on whether you ask payroll or management control, because nobody ever wrote down what exactly was being counted.
  • Nobody can justify the calculation. A figure without a documented method is one a careful acquirer will set aside, or use as leverage in negotiation.

That third point is the most expensive. In due diligence, an unjustifiable figure is not worth zero: it is worth less than zero, because it casts doubt on the quality of everything else supplied.

Which framework applies to you

This is the first question to ask, and it determines everything else.

FrameworkWho asks for itWhat it is
EDCIA private-equity fund, for its portfolio companiesA restricted set of shared indicators, reported annually
PAI indicators (SFDR)An investor subject to the EU sustainable finance regulationThe adverse effects they must be able to document
VSMEAn enterprise client, a bankThe voluntary standard designed for unlisted SMEs
ESRSRarely an SME directlyThe technical standards of the CSRD, which targets large companies

The most frequent confusion is assuming the CSRD applies. It does not target unlisted SMEs. What an SME meets is trickle-down: a client or investor passing part of its own needs along.

Each acronym is explained in our ESG glossary.

How to prepare, concretely

Useful preparation is not about improving your figures beforehand. It is about making them available and defensible.

  1. Identify the framework actually in use by the counterparty. Answering the EDCI when VSME was requested wastes both parties’ time.
  2. Write down each indicator’s definition before computing it: scope, source, method, frequency, owner. That document is what makes an answer defensible, far more than the figure itself.
  3. Rebuild three years of history on the subset that matters. A short clean series beats a long approximate one.
  4. Prepare the list of what is missing, with the reason. An acquirer accepts an absent data point when it is identified and explained. They do not accept discovering it themselves.

That last point often surprises. Naming your own blind spots strengthens the credibility of the rest of the file, whereas letting them emerge mid-process undermines all of it.

The right moment

The ideal moment is before the process starts, because collection is a matter of weeks and a due diligence calendar does not allow for it.

For an SME held by a fund, the question does not arise: the request already lands every year, and the foundation is built once and for all. For a founder considering a sale in twelve to twenty-four months, it belongs on the list alongside the contract review and the tidying of the accounts.


What Pelorus does, and does not do. We structure non-financial data, rebuild history, and prepare the file with its sources. This documentary preparation work constitutes neither an audit, nor a compliance attestation, nor any guarantee as to the outcome of a third-party assessment. Verification of sustainability information falls to statutory auditors and to independent third-party bodies accredited by COFRAC, under Directive (EU) 2022/2464.

If you want to know who is asking you for what and in which format, the 30-minute scoping call exists for that.

Tags

  • ESG
  • due diligence
  • exit
  • private equity
  • EDCI
  • SME

First call on us

Let's discuss your project.

30 minutes to understand your need, no commitment. If we can help, we'll tell you straight.